FourT6and2
Well-known member
JimmyBlind":1qs8n4qw said:FourT6and2":1qs8n4qw said:I don't like Bareknuckle pickups in a Mayones for the reasons y'all have mentioned. BKPs are, by nature, rather sterile. Ok, maybe sterile isn't the right word. But they have clarity and a certain fidelity. When paired with a Mayones, it can be too much. I really like Seymour Duncan pickups (the Nazgul and Omega are my two favs). They smear the sound just enough to give my Duvells character. I'm sure a JB, Distortion, Black Winter, or any number of other pickups would sound great in these guitars. Oh, I actually put a Suhr Aldrich in my Koa Limited and it sounds fantastic too. BKP... not so much.
I'd say if you have to buy a lower fidelity pickup to give the guitar the character it doesn't otherwise have, then that's quite a revealing fault of the guitar.
Totally understand your point of course, but I don't think that's a great advert for these guitars. BKs are the preferred choice of pickup loaded into these guitars from the factory so unless that's merely a sales/marketing partnership between the two companies, then it is how Mayones intended their guitars to sound.
I'd say their guitars are likely aimed at certain genres of music where dynamics are less of a priority. That should be taken into account if someone is potentially going to buy one and wants to play anything other than compressed, homogenized, high gain metal on it.
For what it's worth, I don't like the sound of BKPs in other guitars either. I had a Nailbomb, Black Dog, Holy Diver, and one other I can't remember. Just got fatiguing after a while. Eventually went back to good ol' SD. And I don't consider SDs to be "lower fidelity" compared to BKPs. BKPs just have a certain sound and feel to them. They are comparatively stiff and clear, which is great for some. Not so great for others. The Duvell already has a great deal of clarity. My point was too much of a good thing isn't always the best thing.