Best ear protection for the money - my mini review

311splawndude

311splawndude

Well-known member
Folks,

Your hearing is important so you need to protect it. :yes:

I'm posting this thread for 2 reasons:

1. As a happy holiday reminder to protect your hearing. Once you lose it you can't get it back. That and I've recently learned first hand that tinnitus is a bitch. Get some for yourself and loved ones for Christmas.
2. As a follow up to my thread a while ago where I asked the question which is best. Here:


tl;dr - Hearprotek seems to be my favorite so far

So this new thread today is not a final answer, not at all scientific and not a guarantee. At the bottom I will also show the basic results of R-T users choices in an informal poll taken from link above.

After my informal survey of Rig-Falkers, I found a website called hearing tracker dot com via a Google search. I recommend this site. There were some other websites I reviewed as well, but this one seemed the most comprehensive.

https://www.hearingtracker.com/

From this site I found these as a basis to get started - NO particular order
1. Loop Experience Pro
2. Etymote ER20
3. Eargasm HiFi / 13 dB
4. Eargasm Slide / 12 – 22 dB
5. Minvendo / 7 – 25 dB ($153)


Then, out of confusion and frustration I went to amazon and ordered multiple brands so I could try them out for myself. The thought process here was that I could always return the ones I didn't like. Well, it turns out I like all of them fairly well, so I will just keep them or give them to friends etc.



My final choices in order of preference

Hearprotek - a. 2 sizes included (SNR = 23 rating) Fit well right out of the box. Many size options. Plug is clear. Carry case. $14 for two sets of different sizes.
Hearprotek - b. 2 sizes included (SNR = 20 rating) Fit well, same as above. Plug diaphragm is blue. $14 for 2 different sizes.

Eargasm – 2 sizes, (SNR = 21 for 15 dB) Carry case, lots of packaging for not much else. $32 for one set.

Earpeace – 2 sizes, 3 filters, (SNR = 26, 20, 17) White clear. Carry case. $32 for one set. Didn't spend any time changing filters.

Loop Experience Pro - (SNR = 17 at 12 Db) Carry Case. Mute function. Multiple plug sizes. Loop part is too 'blingy' for me


Not pictured:

Eytomic ER20 – They are connected via wire so harder to lose. Carry Case. Not comfortable for my ears. $22 for one pair.

Vibes - Simple. No case. Effective. Easily lost. $22 for one set. [This is what I had before / I've also had Hearos]

Straight ear plugs like the red ones in the Millwalkee bag. These will straight block noise but not let audio frequencies in.

Foam - 200 pair of foam plugs at 32 dB for $20


YSQOQlfl.jpg



Hearprotek a
ys2NXAql.jpg


Hearprotek b
QZEam2fl.jpg


Hearproteck compare (a & b)
pHgB83ml.jpg


Eargasm
Xb4rSfCl.jpg

B5xIl5Tl.jpg


Earpeace
HcSSGPCl.jpg


Loop
BmloN13l.jpg

EfsnwBBl.jpg






Here is the informal survey from original thread

Cotton – 2
Foam - 1
Hearos – 2
Earpeace – 3
Westones – 1 (must be fitted by audiologist and cost $200 ish)
Etymotic – 2
Eargasm – 2
Daddario dbuds – 1
Hearprotek – 1
Sensaphonics – 1
Decibullz – 1
 
Thanks for the thread. I bought a dB meter last year, and found it was hitting 114dB at certain points. Not good I would imagine. I have a lot of ear pro from shooting, but nothing intended for audio quality. Do they make active ones as well?
 
Folks,

Your hearing is important so you need to protect it. :yes:

I'm posting this thread for 2 reasons:

1. As a happy holiday reminder to protect your hearing. Once you lose it you can't get it back. That and I've recently learned first hand that tinnitus is a bitch. Get some for yourself and loved ones for Christmas.
2. As a follow up to my thread a while ago where I asked the question which is best. Here:

[
Good post.

I go through very bad phases where I have real issues. My ears test fine but fluid builds up in the inner ear. Drives me nuts.
I keep a set of Eargasms on my key chain.
Take care of them for sure.
 
Thanks for this. Even with an attenuator I'm still ruining my hearing. Need to get serious before I mess anything up permanently.
 
Folks,

Your hearing is important so you need to protect it. :yes:

I'm posting this thread for 2 reasons:

1. As a happy holiday reminder to protect your hearing. Once you lose it you can't get it back. That and I've recently learned first hand that tinnitus is a bitch. Get some for yourself and loved ones for Christmas.
2. As a follow up to my thread a while ago where I asked the question which is best. Here:


tl;dr - Hearprotek seems to be my favorite so far

So this new thread today is not a final answer, not at all scientific and not a guarantee. At the bottom I will also show the basic results of R-T users choices in an informal poll taken from link above.

After my informal survey of Rig-Falkers, I found a website called hearing tracker dot com via a Google search. I recommend this site. There were some other websites I reviewed as well, but this one seemed the most comprehensive.

https://www.hearingtracker.com/

From this site I found these as a basis to get started - NO particular order
1. Loop Experience Pro
2. Etymote ER20
3. Eargasm HiFi / 13 dB
4. Eargasm Slide / 12 – 22 dB
5. Minvendo / 7 – 25 dB ($153)


Then, out of confusion and frustration I went to amazon and ordered multiple brands so I could try them out for myself. The thought process here was that I could always return the ones I didn't like. Well, it turns out I like all of them fairly well, so I will just keep them or give them to friends etc.



My final choices in order of preference

Hearprotek - a. 2 sizes included (SNR = 23 rating) Fit well right out of the box. Many size options. Plug is clear. Carry case. $14 for two sets of different sizes.
Hearprotek - b. 2 sizes included (SNR = 20 rating) Fit well, same as above. Plug diaphragm is blue. $14 for 2 different sizes.

Eargasm – 2 sizes, (SNR = 21 for 15 dB) Carry case, lots of packaging for not much else. $32 for one set.

Earpeace – 2 sizes, 3 filters, (SNR = 26, 20, 17) White clear. Carry case. $32 for one set. Didn't spend any time changing filters.

Loop Experience Pro - (SNR = 17 at 12 Db) Carry Case. Mute function. Multiple plug sizes. Loop part is too 'blingy' for me


Not pictured:

Eytomic ER20 – They are connected via wire so harder to lose. Carry Case. Not comfortable for my ears. $22 for one pair.

Vibes - Simple. No case. Effective. Easily lost. $22 for one set. [This is what I had before / I've also had Hearos]

Straight ear plugs like the red ones in the Millwalkee bag. These will straight block noise but not let audio frequencies in.


Foam - 200 pair of foam plugs at 32 dB for $20


YSQOQlfl.jpg



Hearprotek a
ys2NXAql.jpg


Hearprotek b
QZEam2fl.jpg


Hearproteck compare (a & b)
pHgB83ml.jpg


Eargasm
Xb4rSfCl.jpg

B5xIl5Tl.jpg


Earpeace
HcSSGPCl.jpg


Loop
BmloN13l.jpg

EfsnwBBl.jpg






Here is the informal survey from original thread

Cotton – 2
Foam - 1
Hearos – 2
Earpeace – 3
Westones – 1 (must be fitted by audiologist and cost $200 ish)
Etymotic – 2
Eargasm – 2
Daddario dbuds – 1
Hearprotek – 1
Sensaphonics – 1
Decibullz – 1
That is a great summary! This stuff is quite important aparently.

Also surprised that these are affordable. I’ll definitely will have to get some when I get opportunity to move some air with amps more often.
 
@Chase42147 - yeah, these things have come a long way for the price. What I forgot to mention is that most of these said things like "good for 100 uses" or something - which I'm going to have to look into. I guess they wear down :dunno: That is part of the reason I decided to just keep them all. But $20-$30 for a pair of two of these seem like a bargain to me.

@Erock - I actually got dB meter app for my phone thinking it would be a cool thread to get everyone to do the same and then report back their average reading. Bad idea. It prompted me to do this exercise to educate myself.

@dead-pan - Thanks and sorry to hear that. Glad to hear you are doing something about it (no pun)

@gritstogroats - yeah thanks - the ringing in my ear at night is weighing on me

@CrystalSky - thank you and yes, very affordable. Originally I was thinking I was going to invest in some custom ones but after trying all of these out and finding something comfortable, I realized that may not be necessary. I really feel these things have come a long way. :yes:
 
@Chase42147 - yeah, these things have come a long way for the price. What I forgot to mention is that most of these said things like "good for 100 uses" or something - which I'm going to have to look into. I guess they wear down :dunno: That is part of the reason I decided to just keep them all. But $20-$30 for a pair of two of these seem like a bargain to me.

@Erock - I actually got dB meter app for my phone thinking it would be a cool thread to get everyone to do the same and then report back their average reading. Bad idea. It prompted me to do this exercise to educate myself.

@dead-pan - Thanks and sorry to hear that. Glad to hear you are doing something about it (no pun)

@gritstogroats - yeah thanks - the ringing in my ear at night is weighing on me

@CrystalSky - thank you and yes, very affordable. Originally I was thinking I was going to invest in some custom ones but after trying all of these out and finding something comfortable, I realized that may not be necessary. I really feel these things have come a long way. :yes:
do they make any good active solutions? I really like the ones they have developed for other applications.
 
do they make any good active solutions? I really like the ones they have developed for other applications.
Not sure what active is. The Loop ones have a mute function. By active I am assuming they adjust depending on the incoming dB's?

I'll bet some of these $200 ones can do that :dunno:
 
Not sure what active is. The Loop ones have a mute function. By active I am assuming they adjust depending on the incoming dB's?

I'll bet some of these $200 ones can do that :dunno:
active meaning powered noise canceling? I have them for shooting, and they are pretty amazing. They suck for audio though.
 
Back
Top