I currently own 3 compressors. My favorite of the 3 is the Origin Effects Cali76 compact deluxe. Quiet, works well with humbuckers and single coils, and just adds a nice color that I like.
On the other board I have an empress Compressor, which is more transparent and clinical than the Cali76, but still a nice comp and works great with humbuckers. I strongly considered a Chellee compy and Keeley Compressor plus, but decided to play it safe and go with the Empress. My buddy has the Keeley Comp Plus and loves it.
I also have a Diamond Bass comp that I love with single coil guitar and basses, but I find it squishes too much with humbuckers. Used to have a big box Barber tone press and that was a nice comp as well, but it was noisy if you put the blend too high and not good for bass.
In general I seem to either fight compressors with humbuckers, compressors that work well on bass, and that are low noise. So for me the ideal compressor is low noise, works with humbuckers (which typically means a blend knob), and has the frequency response to work with bass. The Cali76CD and Empress Comp check all these boxes. The Diamond Bass comp checks 2 of the 3, but I love what it does for tone sweetening and the tone control, which I will use to add some Jangle to my ric. I run the comps after dirt most of the time.