Which clip sounds better to you and why?

[JakeAC5253]

Just a simple mix comparison of two different (slightly) guitar tones. Tell me which one you like better and why. Also, bonus points to anyone who can tell me what my mix needs and give me some advice to make it better. Thanks

https://soundclick.com/share?songid=9193733

 

[shogun]

the first half seems to be raunchier, thicker, more mids. i dig it more

 

[keano]

funny I hear more clarity and mids on the second.