There are a shitload of Waters’ demos of the 70’s Floyd songs available to listen to on YouTube, they’re basically folk or blues songs written on an acoustic, they didn’t turn into Floyd songs until they were brought to the band and everyone laid their parts down. If Waters was Floyd, as he believes, why doesn’t any of his solo work sound like Floyd?
As for ”Roger’s” basslines, Gilmour played a fuck ton of them throughout the years. If it was a fretless or doing any kind of lead work or the tempo was important, Gilmour played it.
His Floyd-less DSOTM is going to compete with the 50th Anniversary box set of DSOTM. Good luck with that. Gilmour also sang the majority of DSOTM, I think Waters only sang on “Eclipse” if I remember right. So ripping out a fucking legend’s guitar parts AND the vocals that, literally, millions of people are familiar with…fucking dumbass.
It seems the more success he has, the more lunacy comes out of his mouth. He went and hid in a hole for a long time, made it seem like he calmed down and wasn’t as much of an asshole, but in the 2010’s as he started touring, playing primarily Floyd music and the shows did well, that ego came right back out. First he was crying because Gilmour wouldn’t let him post on the Floyd website then it was his usual “those guys never contributed anything, they never had anything to contribute because they aren’t real musicians”.
While going off album sales as a method of deciding what’s good/better is bullshit in popular music terms, I think in this case it works because the only people buying their solo albums are Floyd fans-
DAVID GILMOUR sold
over 2,130,300 albums, including 1,000,000 in the United States and 500,000 in the United Kingdom.
ROGER WATERS sold
over 1,184,661 albums, including 500,000 in the United States and 180,000 in the United Kingdom. The best-selling album by ROGER WATERS is THE PROS & CONS OF HITCHHIKING, which sold over 575,000 copies .
(they each have 4 albums)
Add that to the fact that when Gilmour toured his solo albums, he did about a 50/50 mix of Floyd/Solo songs, when Roger tours he does about 90% Floyd, 10% solo.
All that said, I‘m a Gilmour fanboy, he’s the reason I started playing after my dad took me to see Floyd in ‘94 when I was 11. I’m grateful for Roger’s contributions in the early years, I fucking love those albums, but Gilmour is the reason I listen to Floyd.