Anyone who plays a plexi as in Eddie Schenker Angus etc. Bitch picker couldnt make it happen
100%. This is an inarguable fact, to anyone that's actually spent time playing cranked plexis or other super dynamic amps.
If you can't play aggressively with control, you simply cannot cop those tones.
It's the same with a ton of "heavy" sounding rhythm guitar recordings that DONT even use a plexi. Adam Jones from Tool, for a relevant example, uses much less gain than you would assume - his technique is just so solid, and he corrals his aggressive pickstrokes and makes them consistent. Same with hundreds of other great sounding guitar recordings/records.
ESPECIALLY the guys that are hailed as rhythm playing gods, in metal. Ever wonder why Slayer, Iced Earth, Fear Factory, etc use those huge triangle bass picks with powerline-esque strings? Even though they aren't tuned down a ton? It's because they are hitting the absolute
shit out of their guitars to get those sounds - it's the evolution of the schenker/EVH/Angus technique, used to get super clarity on heavy ass rhythm tones.
@RaceU4her , its certainly possible that you listen to styles of music which don't require this tonal balance, but I kind of doubt it? Many, many seminal heavy metal rhythm guitarists do this to get their signature sounds.
it's definitely true that most of the "shredder" types DO NOT do this - but tbh im way less impressed with Paul Gilbert's
TONE than his
PLAYING. Same with Michael Romeo, Impelliteri, Tommy T Baron, etc.
If you aspire to be like those guys, as a player, I totally get it - but at least as far as TONES go, those players aren't the guys who have the tones people aspire to IMO