I think the issue is that guys inexperienced with recording hear a mic'd clip and complain 'it doesn't sound like that in the room'. Of course it doesn't, but neither do room mics or phone recordings, contrary to 'logic'. For starters our ears are vastly dissimilar to microphones of any sort, and room recordings are capturing the ugliness of your room acoustics, massive EQ curve and phone compression as much as the amp. You do get a somewhat cool flanger effect when the guy moves the phone around the room though!
Whilst there are exceptions, 99% of great recorded guitar tones are via a close mic, so anything else just sounds wrong to me. Maybe if you spend a lot of time on YouTube you adjust to the magnificent tone of phone recordings, I don't know. As I said, really perplexing.