Orange Modern vs Red Modern on Rectifiers, is there a difference ?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Samhain
  • Start date Start date
Welp, sorry to hear that! If you think those are harsh highs I don’t know what to tell ya, people are so afraid of high end it’s ridiculous. This would be almost slightly dark in a mix, which is what matters to me personally.
Where's the mids?? I hear hardly any. The high end isn't really too bright, it's more the character of the high end I'm talking about, dry, harsh... it's not pleasant sounding. I don't know if it would sit in a mix that well with that boomy low end, but maybe. Certainly not a live mix though.
 
Where's the mids?? I hear hardly any. The high end isn't really too bright, it's more the character of the high end I'm talking about, dry, harsh... it's not pleasant sounding. I don't know if it would sit in a mix that well with that boomy low end, but maybe. Certainly not a live mix though.

There’s plenty of midrange there, plenty. Again, I don’t care about live tone, where he’s much more midrange and less bass is often necessary. You don’t need NEAR the midrange people think for recording, it’s a good way to overtake the entire mix real quick. This mids mids mids craze is overly exaggerated when it comes to recording specifically. There’s no eq on this except an extremely Conservative low and high pass. I like to get the tones as big as possible going in, and cut out what you don’t need in the box, it’s extremely difficult, if not impossible to the reverse. I’ll throw it in a rough mix, maybe you’ll get a better idea of how it would sound that way. But the same rules apply to tracking as they do to live playing: you often don’t think you need the sound you do.
 
Where's the mids?? I hear hardly any. The high end isn't really too bright, it's more the character of the high end I'm talking about, dry, harsh... it's not pleasant sounding. I don't know if it would sit in a mix that well with that boomy low end, but maybe. Certainly not a live mix though.
I’ve seen plenty of heavy bands live with tone similar to that cut through just fine, while hitting like a jackhammer, and thats the point of the scooped tone. Get the mids too high, you’ll lose much of that brutal percussion. It depends what sound/feel you’re going for. It’s another flavor that works if dialed in properly. You don’t want the bass to dominate, and you want the mids and highs balanced enough to still cut.
 
Where's the mids?? I hear hardly any. The high end isn't really too bright, it's more the character of the high end I'm talking about, dry, harsh... it's not pleasant sounding. I don't know if it would sit in a mix that well with that boomy low end, but maybe. Certainly not a live mix though.


here ya go... slightly more aggressive high pass (probably alittle too much actually) and a slight tickle of c4, and this is what you get. Cuts through perfect, almost too much... I don’t claim to be a pro engineer, but this is perfectly great for “cutting through a mix”... and there’s not even vocals... I’d be cutting out much more if there were, guaranteed. What you are hearing is the speaker, that may not be your thing, the creambacks midrange is much different than the typical v30, im willing to bet thats maybe what you aren’t digging, and to each his own with that. If I mic’d up the v30 in this cab you’d probably feel alittle more at home with the sound, I’m betting.

https://soundcloud.app.goo.gl/qK87XyGonFVXRwZC9
 
Also to me... this tone absolutely blows away the albums tone... it’s the RIFFS and songwriting that make that record kill, not the tone... at all. The brain fools us all, so many of our favorite “tones” are just killer riffs, period. Great writing, and great riffs ( which this album had in abundance) trump tone and mix... everytime.

Seriously... go listen to that record and then listen to this and tell me the albums tone is less fizzy, sloppy in the low end, less nasally etc than this .. it’s not even close. It’s the riffs and songwriting that make that record kill.
 
here ya go... slightly more aggressive high pass (probably alittle too much actually) and a slight tickle of c4, and this is what you get. Cuts through perfect, almost too much... I don’t claim to be a pro engineer, but this is perfectly great for “cutting through a mix”... and there’s not even vocals... I’d be cutting out much more if there were, guaranteed. What you are hearing is the speaker, that may not be your thing, the creambacks midrange is much different than the typical v30, im willing to bet thats maybe what you aren’t digging, and to each his own with that. If I mic’d up the v30 in this cab you’d probably feel alittle more at home with the sound, I’m betting.

https://soundcloud.app.goo.gl/qK87XyGonFVXRwZC9
Ya, it works, but it's still got that fatiguing high end to it that i'm just not digging, plus the hollowness i'm hearing... just not my kinda tone at all. The playing is top notch though.
 
Ya, it works, but it's still got that fatiguing high end to it that i'm just not digging, plus the hollowness i'm hearing... just not my kinda tone at all. The playing is top notch though.

It’s cool, it’s all personal opinion. The rev F isn’t the culprit here though, for sure. I love my Mesa OS, but at times it gets too... familiar sounding. And the creamback 65 is about the only other speaker I can jive with other than the v30 that sits right in a mix to me for modern metal and sounds right.
 
It’s cool, it’s all personal opinion. The rev F isn’t the culprit here though, for sure. I love my Mesa OS, but at times it gets too... familiar sounding. And the creamback 65 is about the only other speaker I can jive with other than the v30 that sits right in a mix to me for modern metal and sounds right.
Ya, probably the settings and cab have more to do with it. Also, mic positioning could be the culprit??
 
Ya, probably the settings and cab have more to do with it. Also, mic positioning could be the culprit??

Settings are typical recto type settings, with all controls hovering around the noon position. Mic position sure maybe, but most people mic wayyy too dark, the vast majority of newerish bands and internet YouTube dudes all mic their amps wayyyyy too dark. Way too dark. That’s a rabbit hole I could spend hours talking about, because of the extremes of a slight movement of a microphone can change your tone drastically. It’s the number one misunderstood and “done wrong” things that people talk about on the internet etc. many people wouldn’t believe how much high end their favorite records actually have when they solo their guitars, it would be shocking to many really. You need that high end to cut through a dense metal mix. I’ve heard dozens and dozens of solo’d guitars on huge metal records done in the last 15 years, and it’s really shocking just how much high end they actually have. So when I hear people already micing “dark” before they even track or record, I laugh, because the result is almost always the same: super dark murky guitars with no attack and teeth. Don’t confuse “aggressive high end “ with bite either, plenty of tones can be super buzzy and fizzy and dark at the same time.
 
It’s brighter than how I dial my F in but I like bright...coming from the Marshall camp I dig a bite to the tone. That said, it’s very hard for me to dial a bad tone in on my Rev F..in the room it just has such complexity to the tone, very rich especially in Orange to Modern. My Red is a bit more like your recorded tone. I like Red for soloing and Orange for that crushing Rhythm. Both of your tones work for that style imo.
 
It’s brighter than how I dial my F in but I like bright...coming from the Marshall camp I dig a bite to the tone. That said, it’s very hard for me to dial a bad tone in on my Rev F..in the room it just has such complexity to the tone, very rich especially in Orange to Modern. My Red is a bit more like your recorded tone. I like Red for soloing and Orange for that crushing Rhythm. Both of your tones work for that style imo.
Agreed... that’s not a word that gets thrown around much with a rectifier, “complex”, but I most certainly agree, there is a lot going on in the rectos gain and saturation, and that’s a great term for it. The Orange modern just absolutely crushes to me, just a flat out amazing tone. I think at the end of the day what ever demonstrated once again is how important the cab is in your overall tone. We beat that dead horse here and hopefully people see how much influence it has on your sound, which is why I have 5 4x12s haha! I’ve done several different reamps with different amps with this same mic and cab setup today and the results are all strikingly similar, they all fit in this sonic spectrum of tone, and that’s because of the cab I’m using. It’s so crucial, more crucial than the amp in my opinion.
 
Settings are typical recto type settings, with all controls hovering around the noon position. Mic position sure maybe, but most people mic wayyy too dark, the vast majority of newerish bands and internet YouTube dudes all mic their amps wayyyyy too dark. Way too dark. That’s a rabbit hole I could spend hours talking about, because of the extremes of a slight movement of a microphone can change your tone drastically. It’s the number one misunderstood and “done wrong” things that people talk about on the internet etc. many people wouldn’t believe how much high end their favorite records actually have when they solo their guitars, it would be shocking to many really. You need that high end to cut through a dense metal mix. I’ve heard dozens and dozens of solo’d guitars on huge metal records done in the last 15 years, and it’s really shocking just how much high end they actually have. So when I hear people already micing “dark” before they even track or record, I laugh, because the result is almost always the same: super dark murky guitars with no attack and teeth. Don’t confuse “aggressive high end “ with bite either, plenty of tones can be super buzzy and fizzy and dark at the same time.
Yes, you're right. A lot of recorded tones are very bright, but that is not all that works for metal. If you got a more midrange heavy tone you can get away with less high end than what you'd think. Also, most modern recordings are low passed too, not just high pass filtered. It's just to get rid of those annoying high frequencies that are in the upper spectrum, over 10k or so. A good tone should be balanced, but with less low end than you would think. You don't want to step on the bass guitar to much. You can still be brutal if that bass is doubling the guitars tightly to fill out the lows.
 
I don't think that is a good tone at all. It sounds hollow, scooped and the highs are kinda harsh and dry sounding, the playing is tight though.
I think that sounds pretty vicious. Would cut like a knife in a mix. Also think that sounds very similar to a SLO. 😁
 
Agreed... that’s not a word that gets thrown around much with a rectifier, “complex”, but I most certainly agree, there is a lot going on in the rectos gain and saturation, and that’s a great term for it. The Orange modern just absolutely crushes to me, just a flat out amazing tone. I think at the end of the day what ever demonstrated once again is how important the cab is in your overall tone. We beat that dead horse here and hopefully people see how much influence it has on your sound, which is why I have 5 4x12s haha! I’ve done several different reamps with different amps with this same mic and cab setup today and the results are all strikingly similar, they all fit in this sonic spectrum of tone, and that’s because of the cab I’m using. It’s so crucial, more crucial than the amp in my opinion.
Yes the cab is probably the most crucial element. A lot of high gain amps sound strikingly similar through the same cab.
 
Agreed... that’s not a word that gets thrown around much with a rectifier, “complex”, but I most certainly agree, there is a lot going on in the rectos gain and saturation, and that’s a great term for it. The Orange modern just absolutely crushes to me, just a flat out amazing tone. I think at the end of the day what ever demonstrated once again is how important the cab is in your overall tone. We beat that dead horse here and hopefully people see how much influence it has on your sound, which is why I have 5 4x12s haha! I’ve done several different reamps with different amps with this same mic and cab setup today and the results are all strikingly similar, they all fit in this sonic spectrum of tone, and that’s because of the cab I’m using. It’s so crucial, more crucial than the amp in my opinion.
Ya, i wouldn't call a rectifier a complex sounding amp, It's just a brutal sounding amp, kinda cold actually, which is why they worked so well for Meshuggah's earlier recordings, and I believe they used the rectififer model in the axe fx when they switched to modellers for a while. They really need a boost to sound their best too, but that's common knowledge by now.

EDIT: Actually, i take that back. They got those dual rectifiers sounding pretty warm on Soundgarden's superunknown album. Now there's an example of a rather dark sounding tone and it could be considered complex I guess?? but it's not really metal either.
 
Last edited:
Ya, i wouldn't call a rectifier a complex sounding amp, It's just a brutal sounding amp, kinda cold actually, which is why they worked so well for Meshuggah's earlier recordings, and I believe they used the rectififer model in the axe fx when they switched to modellers for a while. They really need a boost to sound their best too, but that's common knowledge by now.

EDIT: Actually, i take that back. They got those dual rectifiers sounding pretty warm on Soundgarden's superunknown album. Now there's an example of a rather dark sounding tone and it could be considered complex I guess?? but it's not really metal either.
Completely disagree. The red channel can be cold and not complex, but on my rev f/c triple the Orange channel is very warm, growly, thick and complex. I’ve been through pretty much all the high gain amps out there except a Larry and the rev f/c triple I have is one of the most complex and warm sounding high gain amps I’ve played on the Orange mode. The only ones I’ve played that are maybe more complex are my iic+, ‘89 SLO, Purpleface Protoype and my Naylor. If we’re talking about 3 channel Recto’s then it’s another story
 
Completely disagree. The red channel can be cold and not complex, but on my rev f/c triple the Orange channel is very warm, growly, thick and complex. I’ve been through pretty much all the high gain amps out there except a Larry and the rev f/c triple I have is one of the most complex and warm sounding high gain amps I’ve played on the Orange mode. The only ones I’ve played that are maybe more complex are my iic+, ‘89 SLO, Purpleface Protoype and my Naylor. If we’re talking about 3 channel Recto’s then it’s another story
Ya, i edited my post. I've heard a few examples of a complex recto tone, but they are really good at the cold, clinical sound.
 
Ya, i wouldn't call a rectifier a complex sounding amp, It's just a brutal sounding amp, kinda cold actually, which is why they worked so well for Meshuggah's earlier recordings, and I believe they used the rectififer model in the axe fx when they switched to modellers for a while. They really need a boost to sound their best too, but that's common knowledge by now.

EDIT: Actually, i take that back. They got those dual rectifiers sounding pretty warm on Soundgarden's superunknown album. Now there's an example of a rather dark sounding tone and it could be considered complex I guess?? but it's not really metal either.
The old revision Recto’s are every bit as good for rock as they are for metal, if not even better in some ways. I’ve been working with my friend on a Re-amping this whole week, his style is more punk and alt rock and my rev f/c triple recto has been sounding amazing for his stuff so far. You don’t hear guys talk about it much, but the green mode on channel 1 with the gain up high can sound killer for a super ballsy, aggressive rock tone (not metal) and that’s one of the sounds we’ve been using. Gonna try it again today but boosting it with my Klon. Although it’s a rock sound (not metal), it’s one of the more aggressive and bigger/heavier sounds I’ve had in its own way
 
Last edited:
Back
Top