top 5 drummers

  • Thread starter Thread starter j666
  • Start date Start date
JamesPeters":a503a said:
ejecta":a503a said:
Neil Peart
John Blackwell
Jerry Gaskill
Matt Cameron
Stewart Copeland

You got the first two I thought of off the top of my head.

Speaking of Copeland...you'll love this...

I was in a restaurant with a friend and the people in an adjacent booth were discussing music. We both decided to listen in on the conversation, while pretending to not be doing so. :)

One guy was essentially ranting to the other about how playing "over complicated" drum parts and making songs which were anything other than basic classic rock, was pretty much pointless. My friend and I nearly burst out laughing at this point alone. The guy continued, comparing Copeland's drumming to that of a bands which did very cheesy basic stuff in the early 80s. He stressed his point by adding, "And where did that get Copeland? Nowhere! Welcome to obscurity, pal!", referring to how seldom he hears The Police's music on the radio. The conclusion of his rant involved pointing out that the music playing over the radio in the restaurant was some basic 80s rock music, which "stood the test of time" and "everyone loves it".

Ever have to fight the urge to laugh so much that it actually hurts your face and stomach? That was one of those times for me.

After we finished our meal, my friend and I watched some TV, in particular the show "Dead Like Me". The theme song intrigued my friend, being far more trained in music theory than I (although I could still appreciate it). At the end of the opening credits, guess who composed the theme song? Stewart Copeland. :) One of the many compositions he's done since he was in the band The Police, which of course is still one of the most famous bands of all time (having sold many millions of albums and won several Grammy awards). Welcome to obscurity indeed.
leave it to you to come in here and write a book! THE NERVE! :lol: :LOL:

copeland roolz...always has. i was amazed when i went back to some of my older police stuff and listened to all the songs i didn't used to like...that whole damn band is pretty awesome. blew me away.

now go work on your theory old man! :D
 
Man, only five is hard. Off the top of my head without thinking too much and not in any order...
Danny Carey (I love his style and dynamics, just a powerhouse)
Billy Cobham (talk about ahead of his time)
Neil Pert (need I say anything)
Dennis Chambers (years ago a friend of mine had a drumming instructional video and I remeber this guy making my jaw hit the floor multiple times)
Derrick Roddy (is there anything this guy can't do?)
 
fearhk213":da859 said:
Derrick Roddy (is there anything this guy can't do?)

Not sound like a drum machine turned up too fast? :D
 
Bonham and then everyone else...

Scott Travis
Tommy Lee
Dave Grohl
John Stanier
Travis Barker

Seriously though, most of the admittedly talented technical drummers listed like portnoy, carey, peart, bozzio etc just havent been a part of any music that I really dig. Props for their chops though.

-dave
 
Gene Hoglan - Dark Angel, SYL, Death, Testament
Witold "Witek" Kiełtyka - Decapitated
Scott Travis - Racer X, Judas Priest
Chris Adler - LoG
Raymond Herrera - Fear Factory

Too much metal for one hand!!!
 
1. Ronny Guyote-deadhorse, and my current unnamed band
2. Bran Dailor-Mastodon
3. Bill Ward
4. Ted Parsons
5. Gene Hoglan
 
Elliot Sellers
Shannon Larken
Brann Dailer
Chris Adler
Marco Minniman
 
no order:


Nicko McBrain
Joey J
Scott Travis
Tommy Aldridge
Tommy Lee
 
Oblivion DC":471ac said:
Gene Hoglan - Dark Angel, SYL, Death, Testament
Witold "Witek" Kiełtyka - Decapitated
Scott Travis - Racer X, Judas Priest
Chris Adler - LoG
Raymond Herrera - Fear Factory

Too much metal for one hand!!!
GEEEENE! fuk yeah dood!
 
scottcrud":84492 said:
1. Ronny Guyote-deadhorse, and my current unnamed band
2. Bran Dailor-Mastodon
3. Bill Ward
4. Ted Parsons
5. Gene Hoglan
ooooooh yeah..."the human drum machine"...is there anybody out there with better meter?
 
I can't believe no one has mentioned Buddy Rich yet. That seems to me to be a gross oversight on everyones part.
 
ToneFreeq89":35f04 said:
I can't believe no one has mentioned Buddy Rich yet. That seems to me to be a gross oversight on everyones part.

It seems to me that different people have different preferences here. :)
 
Tony Williams
Chad Wackerman
Neil Peart
Bun E. Carlos
Nicko McBrain
 
j666":df177 said:
Oblivion DC":df177 said:
Gene Hoglan - Dark Angel, SYL, Death, Testament
Witold "Witek" Kiełtyka - Decapitated
Scott Travis - Racer X, Judas Priest
Chris Adler - LoG
Raymond Herrera - Fear Factory

Too much metal for one hand!!!
GEEEENE! fuk yeah dood!

Old School - Human Thrash Box!!
Hoglan: Aviator Glasses - Easy Chair - Boat Propeller!!
2007-05-21T21_36_00-07_00.jpg
 
vinnie


weckl
smith
danziger

and i think i'm with eddie d. on the nod to sean rickman...the drum tones and mix on powers of ten live are atrociously bad, but the playing is filthy.
 
in no particular order
simon phillips
terry bozzio
bill bruford
neil peart
rod morgenstern
 
Back
Top