What can't James Hetfield do?

  • Thread starter Thread starter rottingcorpse
  • Start date Start date
He can't write decent songs without Dave Mustaine in the band.

I know others disagree, but I do not like a single original metallica song recorded since AJFA

They recorded some cool covers - especially the Diamond Head and Mercyful Fate ones

But their actual records and songs have been completely anodyne and missing a spark of something original or poignant

It's actually kind of weird because you would think they would LUCK into something cool
 
I actually think he's a great writer but Dave's heavy compositions are better than anything James can come up with in that Thrash/Speed vein. Hetfield is miles ahead of him in the vocal department. But Dave is also a better guitar player than the petite Mexican grandmother they've been using for decades now.

 
Can't wait to get rid of kirk and lars

Kirk's guitar playing was honest to god better 40 years ago at the beginning of his career

It's almost like he's specifically fucked off his development as a musician just to see if he can get away with it, or if anyone will notice

And it drives me insane because he lucked into the single greatest gig in all of heavy music and could not be fucked to practice a little bit, once in a while
 
I actually think he's a great writer but Dave's heavy compositions are better than anything James can come up with in that Thrash/Speed vein. Hetfield is miles ahead of him in the vocal department. But Dave is also a better guitar player than the petite Mexican grandmother they've been using for decades now.

The problem is that Dave still has cool songs, that he's writing even NOW

Like, the last couple megadeth albums had some fucking bangers that are light years ahead of what metallica is doing

Seriously listen to this



Dave still actually cares
 
The problem is that Dave still has cool songs, that he's writing even NOW

Like, the last couple megadeth albums had some fucking bangers that are light years ahead of what metallica is doing

Seriously listen to this



Dave still actually cares

Yep, sounds great. And though his vocal is not Hetfield level he writes stuff that his vocal works for. The riffage and solos hearken back to when Metallica was Metallica not a hard rock Bob Seger tribute act. He still cares, and he is still getting better and better at songwriting, his vocals, and gutiar-wise.
 
Back
Top