I went to Sam Ash and a couple Guitar Centers in my city. I tried schecter, LTD, E-2, epiphone, Jackson monarch, gibson LP traditional, classic, 50's and 60's standard, and a studio.
The 60's standard was my favorite followed by the classic then the ESP/LTD stuff. I preferred epiphone and schecter over the traditional or studio.
Funny thing is going in Gibson was the last thing I was looking for. I like the ESP LTD stuff but they didn't have that feel of an LP IMHO. Almost like a super strat just shaped like an LP.
I also tried a heritage that was really nice but it would not stay in tune long and the neck was thicker than my preference.
I also tried a gretsch that was really nice but there was something about it that was hard for me to get comfortable with.
I want to try the burny, Edward's, greco stuff or FGN but I'm always worried that it won't "Les Paul". You guys know what I'm talking about it's just something that is on a gibson that makes it unique. The feel, sound, etc. It's kind of like a Marshall too. When you want a Marshall they just have a little bit of snarl or bark that if that's the sound you are going for you should really just get a Marshall. Sure there are other options that are similar but they are never quite there.