I'd say give the 57 a try. Figure out what you like about it, and what you don't, and then move from there.
I find that if a plain old 57 doesn't sound good, the problem is somewhere else in the chain, especially once you start to drop other instruments in. But I appreciate some people just wanna get different sounds.
I like the Beyer M201, but that's after spending some time with the 57. The M201 kinda sounds like a blend between a 57 and something warmer, I find. But keep in mind, the warmer and/or more neutral mids don't sound as up-front in the mix as the 57.
FWIW, I also really like the 57 on harsh vocals too granted you have a good pop filter between it and the singer.