Proof the Earth is round

  • Thread starter Thread starter 311splawndude
  • Start date Start date
And actually I maintain that creating a formula to predict the effects of the phenomena is not the same as measuring the phenomena. There is no way to directly measure gravity. You are just inferring its existence by other means.
 
Below are the formulas and results for calculating curvature of water due to gravity on the surface of the earth that has a radius of 6371 km. You are the one doing the visual observations. Can you offer sufficient valid evidence that there is no curvature of water over the given distances? What is your proof?

View attachment 349037
View attachment 349040
There is no proof in science only math. I can measure still water in my bathroom tub against a ruler and I will not find any curve. The same could be repeated in a swimming pool and as I mentioned with longer distances with lasers. The onus is on you guys to demonstrate that something exists that is extraordinary. There is actually a colorful history of this very experiment in the 1800s I believe. Both sides thought they won it as I recall
 
And actually I maintain that creating a formula to predict the effects of the phenomena is not the same as measuring the phenomena. There is no way to directly measure gravity. You are just inferring its existence by other means.
The formula was created by observing gravity in action. Because of that we can predict it
 
There is no proof in science only math. I can measure still water in my bathroom tub against a ruler and I will not find any curve. The same could be repeated in a swimming pool and as I mentioned with longer distances with lasers. The onus is on you guys to demonstrate that something exists that is extraordinary. There is actually a colorful history of this very experiment in the 1800s I believe. Both sides thought they won it as I recall

Why would there be a curve to the water in your bathtub?
 
Why would there be a curve to the water in your bathtub?
For the same reason it's supposedly curves around the rest of the globe. Granted I recognize the length of a bathtub would have a very very shallow curve but technically it would be there.
 
The formula was created by observing gravity in action. Because of that we can predict it
That's a circular explanation. You created a formula that can predict its behavior, but you have not identified what it is.
 
Last edited:
Dude, come on
It's true. And I take back actually measuring it because you're not. You can't directly detect gravity. You can only predict the behavior with a mathematical formula. And you have theorized what it is. Fine.
 
For the same reason it's supposedly curves around the rest of the globe. Granted I recognize the length of a bathtub would have a very very shallow curve but technically it would be there.

It would show a curve with the right equipment
 
Flat earthers don't believe in gravity - they say it is simply a matter of buoyancy, like you can observe in a swimming pool.
 
It would show a curve with the right equipment
Yes technically it should. I'm not sure what that equipment would be or how it would be accomplished. The easier method would be to create a perfectly still semi-large body of water and use lasers. Like I said amateurs have been doing this over lakes with no detectable curve.
 
It's true. And I take back actually measuring it because you're not. You can't directly detect gravity. You can only predict the behavior with a mathematical formula. And you have theorized what it is. Fine.

that’s retarded
 
that’s retarded
Look, the fact of the matter is that you can't directly detect gravity. You have a formula that works, and a theory about how it works. Fine. Be happy about it. But it remains that it is an invisible force that you believe is responsible for the way the whole universe works.
 
Yes technically it should. I'm not sure what that equipment would be or how it would be accomplished. The easier method would be to create a perfectly still semi-large body of water and use lasers. Like I said amateurs have been doing this over lakes with no detectable curve.

It should and it technically, and in actuality, does
 
Look, the fact of the matter is that you can't directly detect gravity. You have a formula that works, and a theory about how it works. Fine. Be happy about it. But it remains that it is an invisible undetectable force that you believe is responsible for the way the whole universe works.

You need to step back and think about what you saying. We can detect all kinds of invisible things. Ever hear a sound?
 
You need to step back and think about what you saying. We can detect all kinds of invisible things. Ever hear a sound?
Of course, and radio waves and so on. But there is no machine that can create gravity, at least as far as we're aware of. And there is no instrument that can directly sense gravity like we have instruments that can directly detect sound radio and other electromagnetic waves.
 
It should and it technically, and in actuality, does
This is where I say that you should step back. Everything about the spinning ball globe Earth is taken by faith because we can't sense any of it. We can only extrapolate and deduce by other means. I can hear sound and I can see light. And I can see other waves with instruments that are designed to detect them. There's nothing that we have personal access to in that regard in order to believe that we live on a spinning ball and that gravity exists
 
There is no proof in science only math. I can measure still water in my bathroom tub against a ruler and I will not find any curve. The same could be repeated in a swimming pool and as I mentioned with longer distances with lasers. The onus is on you guys to demonstrate that something exists that is extraordinary. There is actually a colorful history of this very experiment in the 1800s I believe. Both sides thought they won it as I recall

Sorry I didn't mean to use the word proof. Let me rephrase. What is you evidence to invalidate the calculation? Are you saying you can do this with an office depot ruler in your bathtub?

A bathtub should be roughly 1 m long. Demonstrate to me that your ruler can measure a known 0.000002 cm curvature to validate its accuracy. Then measure the water in the bathtub to show there's no curvature.

Granted I recognize the length of a bathtub would have a very very shallow curve but technically it would be there.
Wait a sec... I though you were claiming that water is perfectly level. Now you say that a very very shallow curve would be there. That's the water conforming to the curvature of the earth as in the calculations posted. You've just invalidate your claim for flat earth and validated globe/ball earth.
 
Of course, and radio waves and so on. But there is no machine that can create gravity, at least as far as we're aware of. And there is no instrument that can directly sense gravity like we have instruments that can directly detect sound radio and other electromagnetic waves.

So what you’ve been trying to say is that it doesn’t exist because we can’t create it?
 
This is where I say that you should step back. Everything about the spinning ball globe Earth is taken by faith because we can't sense any of it. We can only extrapolate and deduce by other means. I can hear sound and I can see light. And I can see other waves with instruments that are designed to detect them. There's nothing that we have personal access to in that regard in order to believe that we live on a spinning ball and that gravity exists

you can feel gravity too. It’s just basically the same all the time so you don’t notice it.
 
Back
Top