Unpopular Rigpinions V2

I hear ya...but...whats the good or bad nitro...I have a MJT body that is nitro but not a guitar yet...
I wish I could tell you, but I honestly have no idea haha. That’s a question for a luthier or someone experienced there. Of course it’s all the sum of the parts and I can give plenty of examples of a specific poly guitar sounding better than a specific nitro guitar, but when the specs are otherwise similar, the poly usually becomes more clearly exposed of what it’s doing (suffocating the wood). This is just an area where I’m very opinionated. It really should be unacceptable for an expensive guitar to use poly. It’s cutting corners imo at the expense of tone
 
Last edited:
Resonance is more important than "tone wood"
You can have all sorts of great woods lined up, but if they don't resonate well together, you might as well strap pickups into cardboard.

Bridge and nut is way more important than wood type.

Dimarzio pickups largely sound lame. Geared towards instrumental music. No one cares.

Diminishing returns come in just as fast with gear as it does with pickup trucks
Some good points you bring up, some woods can just not sound good together, but I would add that resonance in and of itself is imo very far from being the most important thing. I’ve had some guitars with excellent resonance, but the core unplugged (and plugged) tone of the guitar itself still was just not that great (like this one James Tyler I had. Very resonant, but tone was just meh)

Bridge is definitely very important and too often overlooked, but from I could tell I don’t think I would say it’s still as a big of a difference maker as wood type (like mahogany vs alder (huge difference there)) or finish (poly vs nitro vs oil)

Haha Dimarzio’s sounding bad isn’t an unpopular opinion, it’s common knowledge lol

I find the more experienced I get testing/comparing gear, the less those “diminishing returns” sound like diminishing returns to me. YMMV
 
I wish I could tell you, but I honestly have no idea haha. That’s a question for a luthier or someone experienced there. Of course it’s all the sum of the parts and I can give plenty of examples of a specific poly guitar sounding better than a specific nitro guitar, but when the specs are otherwise similar, the poly usually becomes more clearly exposed of what it’s doing (suffocating the wood). This is just an area where I’m very opinionated. It really should be unacceptable for an expensive guitar to use poly. It’s cutting corners imo at the expense of tone
One thing I wonder is, the Nitros you own are all Custom Shop Charvels? I wonder if my 08/09 ProMods, if refinished in Nitro would compare. They are nice and resonant; tone wise pale a little to the 84 Charvel I traded you but not that far off. My 08/09s though are damn near mint; maybe I can find a 'slightly beat' 08/09 and send it out for a Nitro refin; and compare.
 
Ok, 2 tears in a bucket, fucket, here goes nothing…

  • There’s no such thing as bad guitar tone, there’s only bad guitar players who have tone.
    • (Don’t 100% believe this myself, but damn it’s funny)


  • Eric Clapton, Steely Dan, most of the sought after vintage guitar tone from the 60’s, 70’s…
 
Last edited:
Silent stage is the death of rock music.

I have never once thought of my rig as my personal monitor, and this silent stage bullshit is ruining rock music. Fine, your little combo or modeler might seem good enough, but the music you are playing is (or should at least be) for other people. As someone who attends concerts as much as I play them, there is nothing worse than hearing the hollow void on stage in between the PA speakers. True fans are front and center (In the fucking pit!), and they are the ones who lose the most for your "perfect mix". Quiet and balanced will never be better than loud and sloppy. Feel it. Turn up your stacks and rock the fuck out! Save your "perfect mix" for the studio.
 
I fuckin love EMGs.

I've tried tons of other stuff including Schecter USAs, BKPs, specialty winds from smaller builders etc...

IDGAF, for what I want to do the fact that I don't have to re-EQ every time I want to track something is priceless to me, plus they just sound badass.
Came to post this. EMGs kick ass. No, they don’t do in between sounds great, but clean and dirty they excel.
 
On your 3, most people that are into music care far less about your tone than you. The drunk cougar with sun damaged skin and the bat wings under her arms wanting to be your groupie knows nothing about tone

On your 4, there’s plenty of classic examples to disprove this.
That was tighter then a dolphins butthole.
HILARIOUS man.
Been having a beast of a day,thx for the laugh!
 
1. No, your boss katana does not hang with tube amps. Expensive gear is expensive for a reason. It only "doesn't make a difference" if you aren't very good. Yes, a decent player can make anything sound decent - but an amazing amp/guitar/whatever can make a decent player sound amazing.

2. Tone is not in the fingers, technique is. By definition, when anyone says tone, what they mean is "the sound of the gear irrespective of the nuances of various players technique." Otherwise we would never have any references for sounds.

3. Tonewoods can and do matter.... sometimes. Of course it doesn't matter which 500$ plank you put emgs in - it's going to sound like the emgs. But just because you can't hear the difference between a Harley Benton singlecut and a Nik Huber Orca with the same pickups doesn't mean others can't.

4. Don't pretend you're an expert (like say, at recording) if you aren't. Don't pretend you're amazing at guitar if youre not. You will eventually get caught. You'll go much further (and get more out of RT) if you're honest, humble, and willing to both learn and share your experiences.

5. Never trust YouTube shills when it comes to tones or gear - anyone who's spent anytime in a/v production knows how easy it is to make a bad sounding product sound great.
Lots of truth here. Tone isn't in the fingers(maybe a little; but not a very high percentage) it's in the gear we all choose to use, and how we dial it in. Playing style/nuances do not equal tone.

5, in particular, is spot on....I have nothing against Pete Thorn and enjoy some of his youtube vids; but one in particular had me chuckling a bit...he was comparing 2 vintage NMV Marshalls with the Suhr SL68 and in the end of the vid, says he prefers the tone of the Suhr. Yeah ok...it wasn't even close. The Marshalls wiped the floor with the Suhr. Haha
 
Never listened to an "unplugged" album or concert video, ever. When I see the word "unplugged" I run a mile.

Bob Dylan is 100% unlistenable to me. I've tried but never lasted more than a few seconds. Like sex, really. :doh:

Master of Puppets sounded spectacular and is still my fave Metallica album.

Grunge does my head in and I blame it for initiating the downward spiral of pop music.

Mesa has balls but lacks mojo whereas Marshall has it.

I absolutely love this thread and the V1 as well. OK, this is probably a popular opinion, but the thread deserves it.

EMGs kick ass. No, they don’t do in between sounds great, but clean and dirty they excel.
Agreed 100%!

I loved recording using analog because it was so simple. All the digital computer stuff is too complicated for old fucks like me who can just barely manage an online presence on a forum and won't join Facebook/Instagram/whatever.
That's me mate. :LOL:
 
5, in particular, is spot on....I have nothing against Pete Thorn and enjoy some of his youtube vids; but one in particular had me chuckling a bit...he was comparing 2 vintage NMV Marshalls with the Suhr SL68 and in the end of the vid, says he prefers the tone of the Suhr. Yeah ok...it wasn't even close. The Marshalls wiped the floor with the Suhr. Haha
He probably preferred the Marshalls and cued up the wrong tracks with his condition and all.
 
I feel the same way about people who constantly swap tubes as I do about people who constantly flip gear :LOL:


Speaker break in is another, I’ve had plenty of new cabs and speakers and never noticed some magical transformation like some claim, your shitty sounding cab is gonna sound just as shitty no matter how much you play it, keep waiting though lol
 
Back
Top