saxxamafone
Well-known member
+1 very well saidIt's a philosophical difference which even exists between players and mix engineers. Amps that are mic'd or through an IR are not a good representation of what an amp sounds like in the room. Some people will not ever track and just want the experience of being in the same room as the amp to play. That is valid. When you track guitars in a mix context, the "in the room feeling" is not important as you are trying to capture a piece of air with a mic that has the characteristics you want in a mix. Way different than capturing allllll the data from the source. That is also valid. It's just about intended use in my opinion and what you value. I think there are some great IR makers and very talented engineers who know how to mic a cab (and also have great gear and great knowlege with how to use said gear to get the sound)--but there are some very bad examples of IRs/traditional recording also. I, personally, do not mind an IR, particularly if it is well done and consistent between amps as I can spot some of the differences with some of the variables removed.